Eero Jürgenson
On the Study Conducted by the ESL Concerning Graduates of Interior Architecture Programmes
GUILD, brotherhood… Support can be found from history even nowadays when we look towards the doings of professional associations. The Association of Estonian Interior Architects (ESL) is no exception as it stands at the threshold of its 24th year of activity in the autumn of 2014 with its 179 members. Every active professional association has to ask itself critical questions from time to time and find answers to those questions – always so that its activity would be meaningful and its visions of the future comprehensible. This is not an overly complicated undertaking when the professional landscape and background of its activities is in stable condition. Yet if social conditions and the background system are going through significant changes, it becomes necessary to relate at the same time to many themes beyond the Association itself. There is a whole series of developments that very significantly affect the professional landscape, for instance legislation, changes in the condition of the real estate market, and changes in how professional training is organised.
Let us return to the years 2010–2011, when the ESL consciously began turning its attention to those developments in the area of the organisation of education that had no rational explanation, at least in terms of established customs in Estonia. New trends in the former balance between the quantity and quality of education were particularly remarkable – the tendency was towards losing that balance. In what sense did this emerge? The number of students graduating from the BA level (the first level of higher education) multiplied during the first decade of the new millennium. During that same period, only a few isolated graduate students acquired the MA level in the study of interior architecture in Estonia. The reason for this powerful change was the fact that two private institutions of applied higher education were added to Estonia’s educational landscape in the 1990’s: the Euroacademy (founded in 1997, EuroUniversity until 2009) and the Mainor Estonian Entrepreneurship University of Applied Sciences (founded in 1992).
At first glance, it may seem wonderful that a large number of student places has successfully been created in Estonia for young people interested in interior architecture. It may also appear prudent that several educational institutions have opened an interesting field of study under their roof with potential for future development. to proceed further from this point, we could tend towards even greater optimism and start thinking that we are a people of design and architecture that knows the field and who perhaps has a great deal to say to its neighbours both to the east and west, and even further afield. All of this is said almost without irony because in choosing an occupation nowadays, it is taken into account that the world is open and the possibilities are limitless, and this is probably true (to a certain extent). We are inevitably left with the impression that the representatives of institutions of higher education do not exchange information amongst themselves while educational institutions at the same time develop vigorously in overlapping directions. Is analysis, critical thought, or the assessment of society’s needs behind this? Is this process planned to any degree or approved by the Ministry of Education, for instance?
Two sister associations (the ESL and the EAL) both adhere to the position that it is necessary to complete both levels of higher education in order to work in the architectural profession. In Estonia, unfortunately, the situation has been enacted as a result of the reform of the system of higher education where one can enter the employment market as an architect only after completing the BA and MA levels of education (integrated higher education). The law does not stipulate this kind of requirement when starting work as an interior architect and it is possible to enter the employment market after acquiring the initial level of higher education (BA). The result, where over the course of ten years people who have acquired this kind of education in Estonia can present 916 BA diplomas and 17 MA diplomas, a ratio of about 1:50, is thought-provoking. Hurrying on ahead, this numerical relation demonstrates one of the results of the study.
What kind of situation does a student at the halfway point of his education find himself in if he wants to continue his studies in Estonia? Enrolling in a reputable school of architecture in Europe or farther afield to continue one’s studies will no doubt broaden one’s horizons. The enriching aspects of this kind of stage in one’s education are beyond any question. The essence of the question is the balance of opportunities or the lack of possibilities. have we now arrived at a situation where continuing one’s studies in Estonia is significantly more complicated than abroad? Does our educational system force young people interested in learning to make decisions derived from the lack of opportunities in Estonia?
The situation emerged in post-Second World War America where the government intentionally reduced expenditures on the costly education of doctors that required a great deal of resources. Instead, young doctors or medical students who had almost completed their training were recruited from less developed countries to complete their studies and residency in the United States. This programme of recruiting talented young specialists proved to be very successful, using the investments made in education by countries with lower standards of living. This phenomenon acquired the designation ‘white colonisation’. Doesn’t the massive overproduction of the initial level of higher education (the BA level) that has gained ground in our country mean the same thing for Estonia in its inverted way, putting many of our young people who have reached the halfway point in acquiring higher education in our country in the donor role of this same phenomenon?
The next round of questions deriving from what has been stated above is associated with the analysis of results. In our profession, we consider responsibility for the design project and the completed object to be self-evident. good practice requires that the author looks after the realisation of his ideas, providing support to the customer while the object is being completed and serving as consultant to the builder. The organisation of education and its implementation can also be compared to a design project that is divided up into stages and the results of which can at some point be assessed, even if only from the standpoint of the objectives that have been set.
What then has been the objective of schools in setting off the developments under consideration here? The ESL does not have an answer to this since educational institutions have not disclosed their objectives in this respect. have the providers of higher education studied the level of satisfaction of their school’s graduates, and to what extent the graduates of their schools find permanent jobs in their profession, in other words what their competitive strength is? Answers to such questions are not found in the sphere of public information. What is quite certain, however, is that different educational institutions in this field do not cultivate cooperation and the exchange of information among themselves.
Not one of those parties has thus far contacted the ESL to obtain this kind of information. This gives rise to a rather wellfounded fear that everything in organising this process has not been accomplished in the best way possible. Let us look further. In the two-stage educational format (BA + MA), there is a major difference in how much has to be invested into BA teaching and how much into MA teaching. While it is possible to organise BA teaching using the ‘conveyer method’, organising education at the MA level is an entirely different kind of challenge for the teaching staff and for the institution of higher education as a whole. Based on the numerical data that has emerged, the immense interest of the institutions of higher education considered in the study in dispensing the initial level of higher education is noticeable. On the contrary, only one of the three institutions of higher education considered is capable of dispensing education at the MA level.
If we for a moment set aside the idealistic meaning of education a very pragmatic aspect remains. In other words, it is important for publicly funded schools to increase the amount of money they receive per capita of students. for private schools (schools that collect tuition fees), it is important to provide a product for which there is a demand on the market. Essentially, both are after a larger base of income. The period under consideration was characterised by an economic upturn and a real estate boom, where the arrows on graphs depicting the growth in Estonia’s construction market showed nothing but a growth trend. Specialists were sought who would be capable of drawing the layouts of finishing materials in design projects, and retail showrooms needed consultants to help draw up orders. BA level training was sufficient for filling this role. Or are the explanations more complicated nevertheless? As the economy cooled down, these former prospects no longer worked in any case.
This topic brings us back to the year 2011, when active discussions started up in the ESL with the aim of drawing attention to developments that at some point would inevitably end up in displacement with reality. The ESL leadership formulated its positions at that time concerning professional training. What follows is an excerpt from the document The Academic Education of Interior Architects in Estonia, Positions of the ESL drawn up on 5 April 2011 at a joint meeting of the Board and the Council of the ESL:
[…]
4. The ESL’s Strategy and Objectives.
The ESL represents and joins together professional interior architects on the basis of its statute, and works towards improving the profession’s quality while protecting the intellectually and physically valuable living environment. today’s priorities should be connected to improving the quality of the preparation of interior architects, and cultivating skills in creating space and professional creativity. The objectives of the curriculum should take the needs and developments of society, culture and the economy more into account. The ESL does not see any need in society for specialists trained at a low level.
5. Proposals for supplementing the curriculum:
a. The prerequisite for working as an interior architect is the acquisition of a complete higher education, in other words the completion of the BA + MA curriculum.
b. The Estonian Academy of Arts should guarantee a sufficient number of student places for MA study (70–80% of the number admitted to BA studies)
[…]
We also wanted to find out the opinion of new or recent graduates and for this reason the leadership of the Association set about making preparations for a study of graduates of the interior architecture programme with the aim of ascertaining the subsequent activity of young interior architects and their assessments of the needs for schooling and development of the profession.
OÜ Faktum & Ariko was selected to carry out the study (the team was composed of K. Petti, tt. Siimar, K. Kall).
Graduates of the interior architecture programme from 2005 onward were selected as the basis for the sample.
Graduates from the three primary educational institutions were considered:
- Estonian Academy of Arts (hereinafter EKA) and EKA Open University (70% of graduates participated in the study)
- Euroacademy (37% of graduates participated in the study)
- Mainor (37% of graduates participated in the study)
Graduates from the most recent years were better represented in this survey.
Summary of the Study:
Motivation for Enrolling in the Interior Architecture Programme
Two motives stand out overwhelmingly: opportunities for creative self-realisation and the attractiveness of the profession. These two motives are overwhelming both as the first and second choice, in other words they overlap with each other. The same pattern of motives is characteristic of the graduates of all three institutions of higher education.
Current Occupation of Graduates
Slightly over half of the respondents interviewed currently work either directly in their profession or in an occupation that is relatively close to their profession. Of the entire sample, 38% indicate that they work directly in their profession and 17% that they work in a related occupation. There are, however, significant differences between graduates from different schools. A total of 63% of EKA graduates work directly in their profession and another 10% in a related occupation. The corresponding numbers among graduates of the Euroacademy are 31% and 20%, while for Mainor the numbers are 23% and 17%. Thus under half of Mainor graduates work in their profession.
The number of unemployed is 7% of the entire sample. Another 10% do not work for other reasons (most likely due to being at home with children). The relative proportion of graduates who are not working is relatively close to that of all graduates with higher education but there are clearly fewer unemployed persons among EKA graduates. In terms of age, persons aged 30–39 with professional credentials form the highest proportion of persons working in the profession. The percentage of persons engaged in professional work is lowest in the youngest group (up to 24 years of age). At the same time, this group also has the most unemployed as well as persons at home for other reasons. Thus the primary question for the youngest group is returning to the employment market.
| Overall distribution | |||||
|
8 |
14 |
33 |
44 |
||
| Estonian Academy of Arts | |||||
|
7 |
7 |
32 |
54 |
||
| Euroacademy | |||||
|
9 |
18 |
34 |
39 |
||
| Mainor | |||||
|
8 |
13 |
34 |
45 |
||
The following table provides an overview of graduates of the interior architecture and figurative arts programmes from 2005 – 2014. Ratio of BA and MA level graduates: 845:17.
* Applied higher education.
** In the 2013/2014 academic year, 19 students graduated from the Mainor Estonian Entrepreneurship University of Applied Sciences programme of design in creative entrepreneurship (with minor specialisation in interior design). The curriculum is the curriculum of applied higher education (meaning the 1st level of higher education like bachelor’s studies).
|
Educational institution |
2005 |
2006 |
2007 |
2008 |
2009 |
2010 |
2011 |
2012 |
2013 |
2014 |
|
|
Estonian Academy of Arts Department of Interior Architecture and Furniture Design |
BA |
13 |
15 |
9 |
5 |
10 |
13 |
16 |
14 |
7 |
6 |
|
MA |
– |
– |
– |
– |
1 |
4 |
5 |
2 |
5 |
5 |
|
|
Estonian Academy of Arts Figurative Art |
BA |
1 |
4 |
5 |
7 |
7 |
6 |
10 |
29 |
5 |
4 |
|
MA |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
|
|
Euroacademy private institution of applied higher education |
BA |
36 |
54 |
50 |
43 |
74 |
71 |
110 |
37* |
39* |
30* |
|
MA |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
|
|
Mainor Estonian Entrepreneurship University of Applied Sciences private institution of applied higher education |
BA |
– |
– |
14 |
16 |
31 |
25 |
29 |
38 |
23 |
19** |
|
MA |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
– |
|
|
TOTAL |
BA |
50 |
73 |
73 |
64 |
122 |
115 |
165 |
109 |
74 |
59 |
|
MA |
– |
– |
– |
– |
1 |
4 |
5 |
2 |
5 |
5 |
|
|
GRAND TOTAL |
BA |
916 |
|||||||||
|
MA |
17 |
||||||||||
Profile of Persons Engaged in Professional Work
From among graduates engaged in professional work, 29% work as salaried employees in small or mid-sized businesses, and another 29% as self-employed entrepreneurs with their own company. The remaining options are less represented. Comparing graduates from the different schools, Euroacademy has produced relatively more interior architects-entrepreneurs. Mainor on the other hand has produced more interior architects-salaried employees.
In terms of the profile of one’s professional work, interior architectural project design clearly prevails (62% of the entire sample). The proportion of this profile is particularly high among EKA graduates (82%), 53% among Euroacademy graduates, and 43% among Mainor graduates. At the same time, the greatest number of graduates working in furniture and product design are from Mainor.
Satisfaction with One's Current Job and Status
Relatively few graduates out of the entire sample are completely discontented or tend towards discontent (15%). Very contented graduates or those tending towards contentedness total 63% of the sample (very contented 26%, tending towards contentedness 37%). Satisfaction is highest among EKA graduates (75% in total). This number is 59% among Euroacademy graduates and 57% among Mainor graduates. Satisfaction with one’s current job and status does not depend to any significant extent on the job or status itself. At the same time, it is nevertheless discernible on the basis of the assessments from EKA graduates that specifically working at a professional job brings with it somewhat greater satisfaction.
Level of Professional Preparation
Assessments of the level of professional preparation at the school from which the respondent graduated are not very high in summary. A total of 44% consider it satisfactory provided that one seeks out supplementary professional training. A total of 36% consider the level of preparation to be relatively good. A total of 5% consider the level of preparation to be very good (41% consider it to be good). A total of 16% of respondents consider the level to be entirely insufficient or tending towards being insufficient. The assessments of EKA graduates are nevertheless slightly better than average – 52% positive assessments. The corresponding numbers for Euroacademy and Mainor graduates are 38% and 32%.
Among the shortcomings of professional preparation, the weakness of the practical side of study and/or its scant connection to actual work, and the insufficient teaching of computer programmes are mainly named. While graduates from all the schools point out the former as an important shortcoming (especially EKA), primarily Euroacademy graduates highlight the scant teaching of computer programmes. A lack of professional subjects is also pointed out to an important extent in the assessments from Mainor graduates.
Opportunities for Finding Professional Work
Opportunities are generally not considered to be good. A total of 43% of graduates interviewed assess these opportunities as being practically nonexistent or quite limited. Only 6% assess employment opportunities to be quite good or very good. The assessment of the remaining 51% is so-so / depends on one’s personal initiative. The assessments of Mainor graduates are clearly the worst (64% pessimistic). Pessimistic assessments account for 45% of the assessments by Euroacademy graduates, and 26% of the assessments by EKA graduates. At the same time, EKA graduates also do not provide optimistic assessments, rather they place more emphasis on the necessity of personal initiative. It appears that the problem of the level of professional preparation carries over more to the opportunities for finding professional work in the case of Mainor graduates as well. The tendency that the younger the respondent, the more sceptically opportunities for finding professional work are assessed, is clearly perceptible.
The main problems in finding professional work are a small market, few jobs, intense competition and scant working and practical experience.
Master's Studies
A total of 44% of respondents finds that the opportunity for master’s studies should definitely be available in Estonia and another third assesses that this opportunity should be more extensive than it currently is. There is no need for this in the opinion of 14% since the BA level is sufficient, and 8% find that there is no need for this in Estonia because master’s degrees can be acquired abroad as well. Thus the need for providing master’s studies in interior architecture in Estonia is considered to be high. Thereat, the assessments of graduates of the different schools are relatively similar. The fact that the assessment of the necessity of master’s studies does not depend on whether the respondent is currently employed in the profession or not is also interesting.
Only a quarter of the respondents nevertheless are directly personally interested in master’s studies in the profession. A total of 35% would perhaps consider it if there were more opportunities. The proportion of interested respondents is similar in comparing graduates from the different schools but the wishes and aspirations of EKA graduates are clearer.
Euroacademy and Mainor graduates do feel the need for a better level of education more than other respondents, but at the same time they are unable to clearly assess whether they would embark on this kind of training. Interest is clearly greater among the youngest group (apparently because they are still prepared to learn, so to speak). Once again there is no essential difference in interest depending on whether the respondent works in the profession or not.
Association of Interior Architects
A total of 63% of the respondents have heard something about the activity of the ESL but are not familiar with it in any detail. Only 13% of respondents are quite well acquainted with the activity of the ESL and only 3% belong to the Association. A total of 16% know very little about the activity of the Association, and 6% have not even heard of the existence of the Association.
Since a ‘vague’ awareness, so to speak, is prevalent, it can be assumed that there is not only a lack of information but also of interest in the activities of the Association. Euroacademy graduates appear to be the furthest removed from the activity of the ESL.
Professional Qualifications
A total of 97% of respondents do not have professional qualification as interior architects.
A total of 24% of respondents do not plan to apply for any level of professional qualification (beginning with level VI) and 61% do not even know what the levels of professional qualification mean.
The content of this study in many respects confirmed the ESL’s understandings and fears concerning the situation that has taken shape.
The study carried out in 2012 can be considered a success and valuable since it includes the comparative analysis of graduates from three schools. A quite good cross section of the sample achieved in terms of both schools and age groups of respondents makes it possible to draw sufficient conclusions.
The ESL had expressed its position that the objectives of curricula should take the needs of and developments in society, culture and the economy more into account. Similarly, the Association does not see any need in society for a large number of specialists with low-level training.
Based on the materials examined above, it can be concluded that the following is needed in planning educational policy for the profession:
– to focus on developing better quality curricula and methodologies to improve the competitive position of graduates on the employment market (not only in Estonia);
– to provide faculty staff with more demanding challenges and higher
objectives;
– to significantly restrict the number of student places at the BA level;
– to make provision for continuing studies at the MA level in Estonia for about 50–70% of students that have embarked on studies in the field of interior architecture;
– to use and develop the potential of EKA as the currently strongest educational institution in the field to serve as the provider of MA studies, including students coming from other schools.
While 456 interior architects/interior designers graduated from the Estonian Institute of Art over the course of the preceding 55 years (1949–2004), 916 graduates received the corresponding diploma in Estonia over the course of the subsequent ten years.
In the current situation, it is very important that consultations concerning the planning of specialised higher education and the improvement of the quality of training take place between governmental institutions responsible for higher education, public and private institutions of higher education (entrepreneurs in the field of training and education) on one side and the ESL and EAL on the other side.
It would be expected that the Ministry of Education is capable of managing and financing Estonia’s educational landscape in a way that rules out disproportional upheavals or would at least bring these phenomena under control in an early phase. The entire process could be guided towards achieving the necessary balance considerably more sensibly with the support of professional associations as partner organisations that know their area of specialisation in depth.
Three proposals derive from comparison of the data summarised above and the conclusions based on them:
- Nowadays, the ESL should be one of the opinion leaders and spokespersons of developing specialty education centred on this field. One of the objectives should be raising awareness of the topic at the level of the Ministry of Education.
- It would be necessary to estimate a reasonable volume of training (student places) and to use this as a guide in practice.
- The EKA should increase its capacity to serve as the MA educational base for students from outside of the EKA, including the best graduates from the Euroacademy and Mainor.
References
Study of graduates of the Interior Architecture Specialty Oü faktum & Ariko, 2012
the full-length text of the study is available to members of the Association at the ESL website
Thanks for generous assistance to: Sigrid Pavel, EKA Department of Interior Architecture and Furniture Design Coordinator of Studies; Kairi Rand, ESL Project Manager