Suzie Attiwill
Practical Philosophy
THE title of the symposium – Dynamics of Theory and Practice – was a key provocation for my presentation – ?interior and practical philosophy – as it connected with a dynamics that has been ongoing in my practice as a designer, academic and PhD candidate. A dynamic also plays out within the discipline of interior design and interior architecture globally. This makes the posing of the topic critical and necessary not only within an Estonian context but also internationally. The following text has been an opportunity to elaborate on some of the ideas I presented at SISU as well as to incorporate insights and thoughts experienced during the symposium that furthered these ideas.
The first part of this essay will attend to some examples of dynamics of theory and practice encountered in the discipline of interior design.1 I then move to a consideration of this dynamic in relation to the profession of interior design. I am using the words ‘discipline’ and ‘profession’ to indicate a difference, one which is perhaps subtle but I think worth making here: ‘discipline’ is used in a way that is inclusive of profession and the academy; and ‘profession’ refers to commercial practitioners.2 This is followed by a discussion of what I see as the unique potential of PhD by practice where theory (or as I will propose – philosophy) is connected with practice and has the potential to make relations between theory and practice as well as bring the profession and academy together in quite different ways. It also enables an articulation of the critical contribution of interior design practice to current local and global concerns.
Interior design, defined as a discipline that addresses the relations between people and environment, has much to contribute to contemporary social, mental and environmental conditions. globalisation, mass migration, urban density and contemporary technologies have transformed people’s sense of space, place, belonging and modes of living. New ways of thinking about habitability and the relation between people and environment are needed.
However my contention is that this requires an engagement with theory and knowledge in a way that differs from how it is generally understood and approached in the discipline. I borrow the term ‘practical philosophy’ 3 from the French philosopher Gilles Deleuze – whose writings have been a critical force in my thinking of the discipline of interior design in different ways. Implicated in a practical philosophy is a focus on ‘how’ and ‘actions’ as distinct from the search for an answer to ‘what is’. This is thinking through doing: a philosophy about what we do, rather than a philosophy about what there is. In conversation with another philosopher Michel Foucault, Deleuze described theory ‘as a box of tools’ that must be useful.4 This generates a different dynamic between theory and practice – one that is in continuous flux.
Why is this approach critical? Interior design is a discipline that engages with life – with living, modes of habitation – and hence change and variation are vital to life; stasis leads to death. This encourages a different trajectory, switching from one that sets out to find a universal solution to one that engages with the processual, where each situation has to be addressed anew.
It also invites attentiveness to assumptions within the discipline and how these can be opened up and re-posed. It is often noted how the discipline has not generated substantial theoretical territories particularly in relation to practice which seems to be driven and governed by commercial forces of budget and timelines. however, underpinning this practice are concepts such as space and subjectivity that have strong theoretical, philosophical implications that produce ways of seeing the world and hence also inform how one practises, yet they remain unquestioned and are assumed as natural self-givens. This is not to dismiss these underpinnings so much as advocate for the value of attending to them, of becoming aware of them, to open them up to the potential to think otherwise – and through this to practise differently and produce new interior designs.
This does not mean that interior designers need to become philosophers so much as invite an attitude or orientation to the discipline which appreciates the philosophical dimensions of its particular concerns i.e. people, modes of being, relations, living. Interior design differs from other design practices that are primarily artefact and/or product-based. Interior design as a practice of making relations, where subjectivity, aesthetics and temporality are the main concerns, is positioned as a practice where the value of engaging with these conditions as philosophical questions has the potential to directly inform and transform practice.
1 Throughout the essay I will use the term ‘interior design’. In Australia, interior design and interior architecture are interchangeable as titles. however the terms ‘interior designer’ and ‘interior architect’ are not – one can only call themselves an ‘interior architect’ if they have met the qualification and registration requirements of an architect. Theoretically and philosophically, I also make a distinction and prefer the term ‘interior design’ as it enables an expanded understanding of practice as one of designing interior that may not be defined as that which is contained within or framed by architecture.
2 For a positioning of ‘discipline’ as a term that encompasses more than the profession see Ellen Klingenberg, Interspace, keynote presentation IfI Round Table Conference, Interior Design; the State of Art, Singapore 24.06.2006. https://goo.gl/6lACO7† Also for a detailed discussion about terminology and the state of the profession internationally see Joanne Cys, ‘[un]disciplined’, IDEA Journal (2006): 14-25. https://goo.gl/7kGCtJ†
3 Practical philosophy is the title of a book by the French philosopher Gilles Deleuze – Gilles Deleuze, Spinoza: Practical Philosophy, trans. Robert hurley (California: City Lights Books, 1988).
4 Gilles Deleuze and Michel Foucault, ‘Intellectuals and Power. A Conversation between Michel foucault and gilles Deleuze’, Michel Foucault, Language, Counter-Memory, Practice. Selected Essays and Interviews, ed. Donald Bouchard f (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1977), 208.
Dynamics of Theory and Practice Encountered in the Discipline of Interior Design
The relation between theory and practice has been an ongoing dynamic encountered in my practice as an academic, designer and PhD candidate in different ways. I studied art history before doing a degree in Interior Design. Art History introduced me to art and architecture, artists and architects where theory was closely linked with practice, which in turn was embedded in social, cultural and political forces; it was also a time of post-structuralism where ways of knowing were positioned as theoretical constructs. As an interior design student ten years later, I was surprised how little concern there was for ‘context’, i.e. anything social, cultural, political or historical. Interior Design felt quite inward focused where poetics and intimacy were, and to some extent continue to be, foregrounded.
In my first year class, a well-known Melbourne interior designer started his presentation by saying all of his work was done intuitively and that he did not believe in theory. I was struck by his clear demarcation and the need to dismiss theory; plus the negation that this was a theoretical position in itself, yet from my point of view, his position assumed a particular idea of intuition that has philosophical lineage which differs from other ideas of intuition, for example intuition as a method as defined by the philosopher henri Bergson.5; Within interior design, I continue to encounter this kind of dynamic.
This is also manifested in publications within the discipline. In comparison to the disciplines of art and architecture, there are a relatively small number of publications dedicated to interior design theory, with most being generated over the past decade. Intimus. Interior Design Theory Reader6;, one of the first interior design theory publications, gathers together a range of texts that connect with the discipline and while the entries may not be specifically about the discipline, they are notable as frequent citations, and hence influential, particularly within an academic context. Interior Design and Architecture: Critical and Primary Sources7; is a collection of already published texts that have contributed to an articulation of the discipline. Toward a New Interior – An Anthology of Interior Design Theory8; is a compilation of selected texts. Each makes a contribution to ways of thinking theoretically about interiors and the curation of the texts collectively generates a theoretical proposition about interior design. Other publications such as Rereadings. Interior Architecture and the Design Principles of Remodelling Existing Buildings9; and Rethinking Design and Interiors. Human Beings in the Built Environment10; offer a theoretical positioning of practice for consideration and debate. And more recently the anthologies: The Handbook of Interior Architecture and Design11; and Meanings of Design. Social, Cultural and Philosophical Essays about People, Spaces and Interior Environment12; offer collections of existing and invited essays which address the discipline specifically and make apparent the emergence of theory and research within the discipline.
This can also be noted in other avenues for publishing research with only a handful of peer reviewed journals dedicated to the discipline – IDEA Journal, International Journal of Interior Architecture and Spatial Design, Interiors. Design, Architecture, Culture and Journal of Interior Design to name the key journals. Conferences and symposia dedicated to the discipline have also provided a vehicle for the presentation and dissemination of research and theoretical positionings. These include AFTER TASTE (Parsons, New York City), Interior forum Scotland (UK), Interiors World forum (Milan Politecnico Italy) and IDEA symposia (Australia, New Zealand). These journals and conferences tend to be situated within the academic world. If the profession is involved, a dynamic between theory and practice is felt – often awkwardly – as one where practitioners practice, academics theorise about their practice and historians contextualise their practice.
The Estonian Society of Interior Architects symposium therefore was an interesting and exciting initiative in this context as it was a proposition that was generated by a professional body (the Estonian Society of Interior Architects) with the expressed aim to bring practitioners and educators together to discuss and debate the state of their discipline. In framing the symposium, tüüne-Kristin Vaikla invited presenters to respond to a set of questions. I have listed them below together with my brief responses. At the time, I struggled with the relation between these questions and the dynamic between theory and practice. however now, after the symposium and my visit to Estonia, I understand the specific issues being raised and how they are critical theoretical issues that tüüne-Kristin felt needed to be engaged with in the contemporary situation of Estonia, and the role that the practice of interior architecture can play. I have included the discussion here as a way of introducing some of the issues raised by the symposium.
‘The collaboration between the professional interior architect and the user has become a keyword of the 21st century. The user?’
I associate the term ‘user’ with products rather than interiors. Participant, inhabitant, producer open up different relations for consideration.
‘Can we still talk about traditions and local identity in the 21st century or has the globalisation process unified us?’
I don’t think that this is an either/or issue i.e. traditions/local identity or globalisation. Globalisation is not just a twenty-first century condition but has been happening for centuries. Perhaps the globalisation we now experience is one through a kind of information globalisation and also capitalism – and hence the sense that there is a sameness in terms of communication.
However any act of production is an expression of local forces – not only through the process of making but also in an ongoing way. The way sunlight falls in a room is different in tallinn compared to Melbourne. Interior design makes site specific – spatially and temporally.
I think it is important to bring into question the issue of identity being raised in these questions. We can think of identity in different ways: as a search for the essence of something that can be pinned down; this is a process then of identifying and recognising something which already exists. however identity can also be thought of as something made and produced, as a temporal and temporary unity (as distinct from an inherent substance or essence). This foregrounds practice and creativity, and allows for variation, movement and change. I suggest it is more important to attend to a way of thinking through practice, rather than identifying an essence, and to pose interior as a contemporary problematic, and interior design as a spatial and temporal practice concerned with making site specific, spatially and, more crucially, temporally.
‘What is the (interior) architect’s crucial role in today’s rapidly changing world?’
The role of the interior architect is perhaps the most critical as it is a practice that enables inhabitation – so the question then is, how to inhabit this rapidly changing world?
‘Are we independent in our creative work – what about the pure aesthetics and marketdriven practices versus ethics in the field of our profession?’
No, I don’t think anything is independent of anything – our practice, our selves are composed of relations and connections. This is an ecological way of thinking about the world (as distinct from an ego-centric way). I also think that aesthetics and the question of subjectivity should be posed as ecological and ethical considerations.
‘What are the main tools of contemporary education of the interior architect?’
To develop a box of tools which enables one to practice anywhere, anytime, anyhow – and in a way which makes specific and singular – as a temporal and spatial habitation.
That the Estonian Society of Interior Architects identified the need and value to focus on the dynamic between practice and theory for its inaugural symposium was significant, and to do this by bringing practitioners and educators together was an important gesture and experiment. for a professional design organisation to organise such conference is rare. Usually it is something that comes from the academy. The need for such discussion, though, has also been recognised by other professional design associations, including the International Federation of Interior Architects/Designers and the European Council of Interior Architects. In the briefing notes for the World Interiors Meeting, 2013, Amsterdam, the event’s curator Kees Spanjers stated that the objective of the meeting was to address the lack of research and debate in Interior discipline. SISU however was different in that it attempted an integrated approach – to bring educators and practitioners into conversation.
5 Gilles Deleuze, Bergsonism, trans. hugh tomlinson and Barbara habberjam (New York: Zone Books, 1988).
6 Julieanna Preston and Mark taylor, ed. Intimus. Interior Design Theory Reader (England: Wiley-Academy, 2006).
7 Mark Taylor, ed. Interior Design and Architecture: Critical and Primary Sources (UK: Berg Publishers, 2013).
8 Lois Weinthal, ed. Toward a New Interior. An Anthology of Interior Design Theory
(New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 2011).
9 Graeme Brooker and Sally Stone,
Rereadings. InteriInterior Architecture and the Design Principals of Remodeling Existing Buildings (London: RIBA Enterprises Ltd, 2004).
10 Shashi Caan, Rethinking Design and Interiors. Human Beings in the Built Environment
(London: Laurence King Publishing, 2011).
11 Graeme Brooker and Lois Weinthal, ed.
The Handbook of Interior Architecture and Design (UK: Bloomsbury Publishing, 2013).
12 Tiiu Poldma, ed. Meanings of Design. Social, Cultural and Philosophical Essays about People, Spaces and Interior Environment (USA: fairchild Books, 2013).
PHD (Doctor of Philosophy) By Practice - A Dynamic Between Theory and Practice
Why is there a lack of research and debate in the discipline? The idea of ‘the real world’ as equated with budgets, deadlines and clients is often cited by the profession as an antidote to the world of the academy, which is framed as conceptual (and by this it is meant unpractical). It would seem fair to say that the interior design profession sees a linear trajectory from education to profes sion where education is primarily training to enter into the profession and once one enters the profession then any further education is ‘professional development’. As a profession it has a vocational nuance with few Masters by coursework programs dedicated specifically to interior and few practitioners with postgraduate qualifications specifically within the discipline. A practitioner with a PhD in the discipline is very rare.
In Australia, the need for postgraduate degrees and research in interior design is becoming a critical issue due to the introduction of Masters degrees as professional degrees for architecture and landscape architecture. This is coupled with changes in education regarding teaching staff to hold appropriate qualifications, i.e. a qualification above the one they are teaching. In Australia, an academic teaching at a Bachelor level requires a Masters and teaching in a Masters degree requires a PhD. If there are no interior design practitioners undertaking Masters or PhD qualifications, then interior design programs will be taught by people from other professions such as architecture and/or people who have no practical experience. This exposes a significant issue for the interior design discipline and its lack of engagement with the larger cultural and social context of its discipline.
At the World Interiors Meeting, Kees invited me to speak about PhDs within the discipline and in particular, the potential and value of practice-based PhDs. The practice-based PhD is something that can be distinguished from thesis based PhDs that address research about design and for design. At the School of Architecture and Design (RMIt University), the practice-based model invites practising architects and designers to reflect on their practice and to research through the medium of design. These PhDs are examined via a public exhibition and verbal presentation together with a written document. The PhD is a contribution which positions the practitioner’s practice in a way that makes evident its critical contribution, its distinctiveness and community of practice; intellectual leadership is offered to the discipline and practice precedents are offered. There is also a contribution to the discipline and through this the emergence of the profession as a critically engaged profession and culture.13;
Yet at RMIT, it is mainly architects and artists who are enrolled in this PhD program. In Australia, there is little interest from the interior design profession regarding Masters and PhDs. Is this due to the particular relation between education and profession described above? What will the effect of this be – particularly as Architecture and Landscape Architecture graduates emerge with Masters as a minimum qualification and practitioners have PhDs? The main research that is happening within interior design is research about and for with an emphasis on scientific methods and evidencebased research. This results in the dismissal of qualities of the discipline such as subjectivity and aesthetics. While I do not want to argue against the value of this research, I think it is critical that the discipline does not neglect the challenges it has in relation to addressing living conditions which are temporal and ephemeral, where design becomes an ecological situation of ongoing change and process; where atmosphere as qualitative and subjective experiences is felt to be vital yet challenges any idea of evidence or systematic repeatability. These are issues that challenge concepts of knowledge and what it is to know. And this is where the PhD by practice becomes interesting in the dynamic between theory and practice.
The PhD as a Doctor of Philosophy introduces philosophy into the coupling with practice as distinct from theory. The proposition of a practical philosophy highlights an attending to thinking through practice; to knowing and understanding the world through doing – through making and constructing. Deleuze writes that a practical philosophy is about what we do, rather than philosophy about what there is. This shifts to a focus on doing that addresses actions as distinct from questions of being and identification.
13 See the following for detailed outline and discussion of this model: Leon van Schaik, The Pink Book. By Practice, By Invitation, Design Practice Research in Architecture and Design at RMIT 1986-2011, ed. Leon van Schaik and Anna Johnson, 2nd ed. (Melbourne, Australia: onepointsixone, 2011); Leon van Schaik and SueAnne Ware, ed.The Practice of Spatial Thinking, vol. 1 Blurb, 2014). https://goo.gl/0jrsph†
?Interior
?interior, practices of interiorisation, interior design is the title of my PhD by practice which was completed in 2012.14 While conducted through practice and project, this PhD took a different trajectory to the reflective-based practice mode. I felt the need to reinvent my practice and wanted to take the opportunity to engage with the ideas expressed in Deleuze’s writing – particularly in relation to interiority and interior – and to think through the impli cation of his philosophy in relation to how to pose the problematic of interior. The dynamic here then between theory and practice was one where the provocation of ?interior became a theoretical intervention through practice.
‘Interior’ is rarely opened up and posed as a question even though ‘interior design’ is a practice of designing interior. ?interior poses the question of interior not as a ‘what’ question – interior? – so much as a problematic in that the question mark coming before the word causes the reader to stumble and pause over ‘interior’. When posed and paused – both space and subject come to the foreground as assumptions and also as concepts which have implicit and implicated theoretical and philosophical underpinnings. While the word ‘interior’ is generally understood as a given enclosed three-dimensional space and as a practice of the built environment, other possibilities proliferate when one reads Adrian forty’s entry on Space in Words and Buildings,15 where he gives a detailed genealogy of the relatively recent use of the concept of space in architectural discourse and practice i.e. from the early 1900s onwards in germany and from the 1940s onwards in English. The human-centred approach of interior design also opens up to expose assumed natural self-givens regarding subject and subjectivity as inflected with ways of understanding that privilege individuals as isolated, self conscious subjects, i.e. phenomenological and psychological subjects. Time is also another philosophical concern that has much potential to engage the discipline if addressed through a practical philosophy. As a discipline that addresses habitation and hence living, the relations with and between present, past and future become a proposition to design also – whether the past is something preexisting to represent, how memory is present etc. Reading Deleuze’s writing on henri Bergson – Bergsonism16 – raises the idea of thinking time different from a spatialised time as a movement from one point to another. Instead, an immersive ‘in time’ invites a different way of designing and interiorizing.
These thoughts demonstrate the potential of approaching assumptions of the discipline as philosophical concepts to make them dynamic through an engagement of theory and practice so they become tools for practice and the production of the new. In turn, a practical philosophy through the practice of interior design emerges which engages the dynamic between theory and practice in ways that differ from relations between theory and practice where theory is applied to practice or practice is theorized.
The twenty-first century as ‘the century of the city’17< needs new ways of thinking about habitability and the relation between people and environment. The potential of interior design to address concepts of space, time, subjectivity, interior and interiority through a practice of design becomes critical, exciting and vital. The discipline needs practitioners engaged in PhDs by practice that produce practical philosophies which articulate the production of interior, interiority and interior designs. In designing for life, research is not a search for one universal solution so much as an appreciation of life as process and hence change, chance, variation and difference. The question of how to design for this requires a dynamic between theory and practice that does not seek certainty so much as engages ‘in the continuous development of its practices as much as its theoretical scaffolding’.18 The value of this dynamic is critical to the discipline and living.
14 Suzie Attiwill, ‘?interior, practices of interiorization, interior designs’ (PhD thesis, RMIt University, 2012). https://goo.gl/zrbmcL† And an edited version available Suzie Attiwill, ‘?interior, practices of interiorization, interior designs’, The Practice of Spatial Thinking. Volume One, ed. Leon van Schaik and SueAnne Ware (Blurb, 2014). https://goo.gl/RLjCJa†
15 Adrian forty, Words and Buildings. A Vocabulary of Modern Architecture (UK: Thames & hudson, 2000).
16 Gilles Deleuze, Bergsonism, trans. Hugh Tomlinson and Barbara Habberjam (New York: Zone Books, 1988).
17 Anna Kajumulo tibaijuka, ‘Inaugural Address UN Pavilion Lecture Series’, Shanghai World Expo 2010, 2010. https://goo.gl/OEbztW†
18 félix guattari, The Three Ecologies, trans. Ian Pindar and Paul Sutton (London: Continuum, 2008), 27.